Anti-vaxxers and covid-19

An effective vaccine against the covid-19 virus is faraway. Even after identifying a good vaccine, it would take a lot of time to produce sufficient amount of vaccine to inoculate the world population. Whether younger people should be vaccinated for herd immunity (perhaps 70% of the population) would depend on the effectiveness of the vaccine. 
I suspect that older people would be given higher priority given that older people are more likely to die from the covid-19 virus. It is also probable that a lottery system would be used to determine who gets the vaccine first. For example in the USA, we could use the last number of the social security number (e.g. 0 first, then 1 next, etc). This is not a perfect system since not every USA resident has a social security number. 
As for the anti-vaxxers, at this time I cannot think of a single reason to force someone to get vaccinated - even those who are a part of the most endangered demographics - covid-19 is not measles, which is a big problem for the young, and there is no requirement even for measles vaccine for natural-born USA citizens. (BTW, immigrants to the USA are required to be vaccinated against a number of diseases including measles.) My inclination is that anti-vaxxers have a right-to-die. I don't foresee a public health reason to try to get 99% vaccination rate with covid-19, and I very much doubt that anti-vaxxers make up 10% never mind 30% of the USA citizenry. We cannot save those who refuse help.
If someone can think of a contrary reasoning, let me know - I have an open mind. Meanwhile, my recommendation in dealing with anti-vaxxers regarding covid-19 is - ignore them - let them die if that's what they want.
p.s. I suspect that many people came to a similar conclusion already. While I see some people sprouting anti-vaccine stances, no one seems bothered enough to engage/oppose them. I suppose it's not polite to say, "You have a right to die."

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

An update on the state of covid-19 in the 50 US states

Image
How are we doing with covid-19? Is the situation improving or worsening? How is it for different parts of the USA? How do we assess the situation? The best measures are the number of covid-19 confirmed cases, covid-19 induced deaths, and testing statistics. Each measure has weaknesses. Many people think that confirmed cases vastly underestimate the true spread of the disease - because of limits in testing. However, deaths could be also both overcounted and undercounted . Some analysts largely ignore the number of confirmed cases and focus solely on the number of deaths. Many such analysts estimate true spread of infection assuming a fixed death rate, which is not easy to determine. Rather small differences in the death rate could make a huge difference in the estimated spread of disease. Examples  here and here . While different methods have their merits, policy decisions should be based on all available information - regardless of the shortcomings of each measure. In additi...
Read more

Current prospects on covid-19 herd immunity

Herd immunity provides indirect protection to those who are not immune to the disease. Herd immunity requires that most of a population be immune - depending on how contagious an infection is, usually 70% to 90% of a population needs immunity to achieve herd immunity.  Given that we don't have an effective vaccine against covid-19 virus, is it reasonable to try to achieve herd immunity against this virus? The short answer is no, but we could imagine trying.  First consider how many people would die trying to achieve herd immunity. For now, we will ignore long-term complications for those who recover from severe illness.  To gauge death rate, and we need accurate number of all dead and of all infected. With most countries including the USA, Italy, and China, we don't know the true extent of infection. The two most reliable cases are the cruise ship Diamond Princess (13 dead out of 712 infected = 1.8% death rate) and South Korea (256 dead out of 10810 infected = 2.4%...
Read more

Population density and covid-19 with 50 US states

Image
Many factors including luck play a role in covid-19 spread, including government policy, healthcare readiness, citizen response, demographics, and luck. Different countries are going to be affected differently, and bigger more populous countries have more people 'available' to be infected and killed. Here, I talk about another factor - population density. Higher population density makes it easy for disease to spread more widely. Thus, cities are more strongly affected than suburbs, which are in turn more strongly affected than rural areas. In addition to dividing the number of confirmed cases (or deaths) by population size, we can look at the epidemic in terms of population density. Below, I show a snapshot of daily cases averaged across last 7 days against population density for the 50 US states. It should be pretty clear that states with higher population density tends to be with more new confirmed cases per million. This should not surprise anyone with basic knowledge of d...
Read more